"This makes me proud because the Hopi Tribe has already taken a step to meet those requirements. All of this helps Hopi and other tribes strengthen control over the crimes that happen on their land. Tribal sovereignty is truly a valuable asset but it also gives us that opportunity to exercise that sovereignty by developing the laws and actually implementing them."Fred Urbina, the chief prosecutor for the Pascua Yaqui Tribe is anxious to follow in the path of the Hopi and get the tribe in a position to implement VAWA. In an AP story today, he described the tribe's efforts to address the jurisdictional gap as a "patchwork" that is "not satisfactory in all cases."
But as both Shingoitewa and Urbina pointed out, implementing the laws is key. A Harper's article from 2011 explored the different obstacles to reporting, documenting, investigating and prosecuting rape cases, none of which would be affected by the new VAWA law or by enhanced sentencing. Only systemic change, including increased funding, training and data collection could change the conditions that lead to what a U.S. prosecutor told Hopi nurses and officers was a "culture of silence," when it came to sexual and domestic violence.
If the laws are implemented, detention is another key part of what tribes need to address. BIA prisons are insufficient for current populations; it's unlikely that enhanced sentencing and prosecuting more domestic violence cases will help that. With everything else in place, even the Hopi are still seeking funding for new detention facilities.
Posts
